"How to Kill a Transperson"
Feb. 15th, 2008 12:21 pm( How to Kill a Transperson )
The existence of persons who are physically intersex is a great big out-of-context problem for social conservatives who assert that "marriage should always be between one man and one woman". They can dismiss transexual⁄transgender people as "mentally disturbed perverts", but they cannot deal with the fact that there are people who naturally fall outside the gender binary; they have no answer to the question, God gave me both a penis and breasts. Which am I supposed to marry, a man or a woman?
Assuming they don't simply refuse to answer, social conservatives will tie themselves into knots trying to decide whether physical appearance or genetic makeup is a more accurate indicator of God's Will; failing to find an answer, they will usually declare that intersexed persons aren't allowed to have relationships at all unless they're "mostly" male or female and can be "fixed". They will almost invariably follow this up by claiming that intersex conditions are "extremely rare birth disorders" (which is absolutely false; they're playing games with the definition of intersex) and then going on to argue that intersex people should be ignored for the purposes of public policy because acknowledging them would fatally compromise traditional gender roles.
In other words, Your existence gives me a headache, so I demand that everyone has to pretend that you don't exist.
.
I think we do need to go out and rub their faces in the sheer illogic of it all, because once they're forced to acknowledge that This Really Happens, their case against transgender in general falls all to pieces.